The Yogurt Shop Murders documentary poster
True Crime

The Yogurt Shop Murders

2025 45m ⭐ 6.5/10 Documentary · Crime

In 1991, four teenage girls were murdered at a frozen yogurt shop in Austin, Texas — a case that shook the city and, decades later, still hasn't produced a conviction that has held up.

▶ Watch on Neon 🔍 Find more docs

Details

Year
2025
Runtime
45m
Rating
6.5 / 10
Format
TV Series
Seasons
1
Country
United States of America
Platform
Neon

Why Watch This

This is one of the more frustrating cases in the genre: multiple suspects were charged and later cleared or had convictions overturned, and the series is upfront about how badly the original investigation was mishandled rather than pretending it has answers it doesn't.

If The Yogurt Shop Murders' unresolved, wrongful-suspicion angle got to you, Murder in the Heartland and Till Murder Do Us Part: Soering vs. Haysom sit in that same uneasy territory.

Where to Watch

RegionAvailablePlatform
New ZealandNeon
Australia
United States
United Kingdom
Canada
Ireland

Frequently Asked Questions

Has the Yogurt Shop case been solved?
No. Two men were originally convicted but had their convictions overturned on appeal, and the case remains officially unsolved as of 2026.
How many episodes are there?
Five episodes, released across 2025 and 2026.
Why did the original convictions get overturned?
Courts found the confessions used to convict the two original suspects were unreliable and improperly obtained.
Where can I watch it in NZ?
The Yogurt Shop Murders is streaming on Neon New Zealand.

More True Crime Docs