American Nightmare documentary poster
True Crime

American Nightmare

2024 45m ⭐ 7.4/10 Documentary · Crime

After Denise Huskins is kidnapped from her Vallejo, California home, police dismiss the case as a hoax staged by her and her boyfriend, comparing it to the movie Gone Girl — until another attack changes everything.

▶ Watch on Netflix 🔍 Find more docs

Details

Year
2024
Runtime
45m
Rating
7.4 / 10
Format
TV Series
Seasons
1
Country
United States of America
Platform
Netflix

Why Watch This

From the team behind The Tinder Swindler, this is a slow-burning study in institutional failure. The most damning material isn't the crime itself but the interrogation footage, showing exactly how police talked themselves into blaming the victims instead of following the evidence. It's a hard watch, but a useful one — the couple ultimately won a defamation settlement from the department that accused them.

If American Nightmare left you angry at the system rather than just the criminal, Missing: The Lucie Blackman Case and One Night in Idaho cover investigations with their own institutional stumbles.

Where to Watch

RegionAvailablePlatform
New ZealandNetflix
AustraliaNetflix
United StatesNetflix
United KingdomNetflix
CanadaNetflix
IrelandNetflix

Frequently Asked Questions

Is American Nightmare a true story?
Yes, it recounts the real 2015 kidnapping of Denise Huskins and the police investigation that wrongly branded it a hoax.
Who was actually responsible?
Matthew Muller, a former attorney, was later connected to the crime through a similar home invasion and convicted.
How many episodes are there?
Three episodes.
Where can I watch it in NZ?
American Nightmare is streaming on Netflix New Zealand.

More True Crime Docs